We're available through e-mail, live chat and Facebook. There are seven "In Verrem" speeches, but five were never given because Verres fled before the trial ended. Why was that pirate kept out of sight? (Cicero, 2006, 66) Cicero uses a rhetorical question here, knowingly putting Verres on the spot. T.D. Cicero would serve in Sicily in 75 BC as a quaestor, and in doing so made contacts with a number of Sicilian towns. When slandering him he placed the focus on his un-Roman behaviour as he knew it would upset and anger the jury, ensuring that they would vote against him. He held the positions of Roman senator and Roman consul (chief-magistrate) and played a critical . The Philippics round out Cicero's life, as Marcus Antonius eventually has occasion to have him murdered. By use of slander and comparison he was able to showthe extent of Verres crimes and bad character, speaking of his laziness, partying, thievery among others. Mithridates, the king of Pontus, was at war with Rome over several territories. ABOUT THE STATUES THE ARGUMENT The subject of this oration is the manner in which Verres had plundered not only private individuals, but even some temples, of valuable statues, and other works of art. nt. This example would have also been used to remind the people that Verres did not follow Roman laws, showing him as someone who thought he was above everyone else and that the customs did not apply to him. In 81 BC, the Dictator Lucius Cornelius Sulla Felix had changed the composition of criminal courts, allowing only Senators to serve as jurymen. In 81 BC, the Further, to counteract Hortensius' attempts to draw the trial out, Cicero begged the court's indulgence to allow him to alter the trial's flow from the usual format. These speeches were given in 70 B.C. By doing this Cicero is able to undermine any power that Verres once had. Cicero here reconsiders events that happened about a decade earlier, in an effort to portray Verres as evil through and through. Excerpts from an English translation of the speeches are published in "Introduction: 5 Books of the Second Action Against Verres", in C. D. Yonge, ed., This page was last edited on 2 October 2022, at 20:29. Other notable orations include the Pro Caelio, Pro Milone and the Phillipics against Marc Antony (largely responsible for Cicero's prosecution and execution). 0000010417 00000 n
In Verrem I. Similarly during section 31 Cicero sarcastically mocks Verres claim that he helped to save Sicily during the war against the slaves. Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like Date of Trial, and where it took place, Cicero acted as, Verres was accused of and more. He also meditates upon the extraordinary violation of these values represented by the crime of parricide, requiring a level of depravity incongruous with Roscius Jnr's good character. Pompei ('On the Command of Gnaeus Pompeius'), teaching or studying Selected Political Speeches of Cicero. M. TVLLI CICERONIS ORATIONES IN VERREM. Cicero was able to speak directly to the emotions of the jury, bringing up Verres many crimes and how they affected the people of Rome.
]8 ]Qb;
m(L>c 0000015047 00000 n
Outline of the main charges in second speech, "Cornelius (RE 135) Dolabella (2), Gnaeus", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=In_Verrem&oldid=1113695649, He ordered ships that had valuable cargoes impounded as allegedly belonging to the rebel, one prisoner of Verres' scheme, Publius Gavius, a Roman citizen of Compsa, escaped and protested about Verres' treatment of Roman citizens. 2.1 is primarily a warm-up to his account of Verres governorship of Sicily, to which he devoted the four subsequent speeches.23. Anonymous "Ciceros Orations Summary". The second prong concerned Verres' defense's attempts to keep the case from proceeding on technicalities. The speech argues in favor of retaining Pompey's command. Verres' pockets were sufficiently deep for an extensive campaign of bribery. The eighth speech, "Pro Marcello" congratulates then dictator Caesar on pardoning his old rival Marcellus. Verres had the man flogged, and then he had him crucified, both punishments not to be inflicted on a Roman citizen without a trial in Rome (and even then, an execution by. You do not imagine that you have a share in the glory with Marcus Crassus or Gnaues Pompeius? (Cicero, 2006, 31) He then goes on to add that Crassus had Courage and foresight, and was Valiant, (Cicero, 2006, 31) Making it clear that Crassus, along with Pompeius, were men who put in effort to help during the war and that Verres did little to nothing and was just taking credit for others hard work. 0000010523 00000 n
nominis delatio and nominis receptio (c. 20 January 70 or soon thereafter): after his victory over Caecilius, Cicero submitted a formal charge (nominis delatio), which was accepted by the praetor (nominis receptio). Contrast the treatment of Syracuse by Marcellus in war and by Verres in peace Noun Nom. The following very brief summary of Cicero's life is drawn from the Oxford Classical Dictionary. This can be seen during his use of the other techniques discussed. will review the submission and either publish your submission or providefeedback. These speeches are highly political, particularly In Verrem I. Verres, In the second, infinitely more damning speech, Cicero laid out the full charge sheet. The first oration against Verres. Yet while it is the centre of Ver. THE FOURTH BOOK OF THE SECOND PLEADING IN THE PROSECUTION OF VERRES. 0
Cicero won the case against major resistance. "In Verrem I" is the first of these speeches. In Verrem II.2. Best summary PDF, themes, and quotes. Cicero ultimately knows that by succeeding to get the jury on his side is a sure victory. An example of this comes during section 23 as he states, But how he incriminated himself in the first hearing. (Cicero, 2006, 73) Cicero includes no sense of uncertainty that Verres may be innocent, making it easier for the jury to see the us vs them narrative he wants to enforce. $n$0 ~=>8&j+|Y(.t+y#KOM$@]Q,K,jq4EAm4TF U8
: Chapter I, In Verrem I Summary and Analysis. The first speech intended for the second hearing (Ver. Selected Political Speeches of Cicero from, Order our Selected Political Speeches of Cicero Study Guide, Chapter 3, De imperio Cn. Hortensius and Verres both knew, Cicero argued, that Marcus Metellus, a friend and ally of Verres, would be in charge of the extortion court in the new year, and so saw a benefit to such a gaming of the system. Instead, he took a two-pronged approach, by both inflating the vanity of the all-Verres had secured the services of the finest orator of his day, The point of the attempted derailment of the case hinged on Roman custom. Written by people who wish to remainanonymous. The actio secunda, for which Cicero had prepared a massive amount of material adding up to five full speeches, never took place. In all of his published orations, Cicero maintains the illusion that the text is the record of a performance. It never reconvened: Verres considered the case that Cicero presented against him during the first hearing so compelling that he went into voluntary exile. He saw the tides of the war shifting to Sulla, and so, Cicero alleged, went over to Sulla's lines bearing his legion's paychest. In 70 BC Cicero, who had served as quaestor in Sicily five years previously, was commissioned by the Sicilians to prosecute the island's former governor, Gaius Verres, for corruption. in Verrem 2.3: Sicily - extortion of taxes. when Hortensius and an ally would be elected to consulships and their friend Marcus Metellus elected praetor and president of the extortion court (read more from the Chapter I, In Verrem I Summary), Get Selected Political Speeches of Cicero from Amazon.com. Tempests statement can be considered as accurate as without audience involvement, the speech would not have worked as well. Significant quotes in Cicero's In Verrem with explanations. The so-called Verrine Orations thus comprise the Divinatio in Caecilium (Preliminary hearing against Caecilius'), which won him the right to act as prosecutor of Verres; the decisive speech he gave during the first hearing (in Verrem 1); and the material Cicero prepared for the second hearing, repackaged into five undelivered orations (in Verrem 2.1-5).1 The dissemination of this corpus of speeches constituted an unprecedented enterprise, the largest single publication of [his . IvyMoose is the largest stock of essay samples on lots of topics and for any discipline. Caesar had also lifted Cicero's exile; this was his first speech since his return. When comparing Verres to someone Cicero made sure that he used a well known Roman figure that his audience would recognize. Any deadline. in Verrem 2.5: Sicily - Verres as magistrate with imperium, responsible for public safety and endowed with the power to punish Cicero only decided to publish a selection of his speeches. The next speech is "In Verrem II.5." samples are real essays written by real students who kindly donate their papers to us so that Cicero placed his focus on convincing the jury of the fact that Verres actions were un-Roman, something that would have been successful due to the importance of Roman values. This paper offers the story of Marcus Tullius Cicero, expounding upon the great Roman lawyers role in the trajectory and development of Natural Law Theory (which is arguably the foundation for the existence of all Western democracies and Republics). Verres, who had been a Roman magistrate and governor was being put on trial for numerous charges, including taking art for his own collections, executing Roman citizens in place of pirates, using methods of execution deemed only suitable for slaves by Roman law and seizing money from the citizens. general offensive and tudd song of storms, best exfoliating mask for combination skin, warner theater grand suites seating chart. 4 The dissemination of this corpus of speeches constituted an unprecedented enterprise, "the largest single publication of [his] entire . From Syracuse to Rome: The Travails of Silanion's Sappho. Transactions of the American Philological Association, vol. New!! In it, Cicero took advantage of the almost unconditional freedom to speak in court to demolish Verres' case. One of Cicero's greatest acts as consul was to quell this conspiracy. 0000001596 00000 n
Section 28 is notable for this, one of the lines being that, All his entertainment ended up with someone being carried as if from a battlefield. (Cicero, 2006, 28) This includes one of the many instances that Cicero brings up Verres partying. After defending Sextus Roscius of Ameria in 80 BC on a highly politically charged case of parricide, Cicero left for a voyage to Greece and Rhodes. However, it was his use of involving the audience that made In Verrem so effective. Cicero formally charged Verres with extortion of 40 million sesterces A penalty of 100 million sesterces (maximum allowed by law) 2. 0000008050 00000 n
resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss thenovel. This paper argues that Ciceros victory in the trial known as In Verrem changed the course of jurisprudential history due to the rise of the Cicero as a result of said victory, which permitted him to significantly influence Roman republican jurisprudence. These relatives, Magnus and Capito, allegedly worked in collusion with the high-ranking official Chrysogonus to legally seize the defendant's inheritance through the era's terrifying proscriptions campaign. However, this compilation does not include any of those works. Note: All essays placed on IvyMoose.com are written by students who kindly donate their papers to us. At the time the case was being argued, the year was coming to a close and soon a number of public festivals (including one in honor of Pompey the Great) would commence. Cicero is serving as prosecutor against the infamously corrupt governor of Sicily, Verres. In Verrem is another notable oration, wherein Cicero represented the province of Sicily to prosecute the corrupt governor Verres for changes of corruption and extortion. [1], Afterwards, he was protected to a degree by Sulla, and allowed to indulge a skill for gubernatorial extortion in Cilicia under the province's governor, Gnaeus Cornelius Dolabella in 81 BC. Create your own Vocabulary Lists, share them with friends or colleagues. religio, religionis Fsupernatural constraint/taboo; obligation; sanction; worship; rite; sanctity. Report Copyright Violation Summary 7.49 Add to cart Add to wishlist 100% Money Back Guarantee Both online and in PDF Big, Bad Bug, Selected Political Speeches of Cicero Summary & Study Guide Description. Selected Political Speeches of Cicero Summary & Study Guide includes comprehensive information and analysis to Skip to main content. pl. The first speech, "In Verrem I" is one of two 'juridical' orations included in the book - it is given in court and is intended to defend or convict a defendant. In 69, Hortensius, one of his advocates, and Q. Caecilius Metellus Creticus, one of his main friends and supporters, would have been consuls, and M. Caecilius Metellus (a brother of the aforementioned Metellus) would have presided over the extortion court as praetor. In addition, Hortensius himself, along with Quintus Metellus, Marcus's older brother, had been elected consuls for the same year, and would thus be in prime position to intimidate the witnesses when the case resumed after the expected lull. No clear consensus has emerged, not least since his practice will most likely have differed from case to case, ranging from almost instant release with only minor adjustments to significant revision and publication several years after the original delivery.20 The speeches that Cicero prepared for the second hearing belong to those that he anyway never gave, so here the question is moot. 0000011194 00000 n
Verres had secured the services of the finest orator of his day, Quintus Hortensius Hortalus for his defense. 0000000897 00000 n
"De imperio Cn. In Verrem. In fact a large amount of his clientele at the time came from Sicily, a link that would prove invaluable in 70 BC, when a deputation of Sicilians asked Cicero to level a prosecution against Verres for his alleged crimes on the island. Unser Laden; 02571/5 69 89 33 persnlicher Kundenservice; Anmelden; 0 Artikel 0,00 ; Menu Menu . To conclude, Ciceros speech was helped by his use of various techniques that enforced the idea that Verres was not fit to be a Governor of Rome. Cicero is serving as prosecutor against the infamously corrupt governor of Sicily, Verres. It would have been Ciceros practice in any case to work up extensive written notes for a speech before its oral delivery which of course does not mean that he read from a script in court and he most likely had his contribution to the actio secunda more or less ready to go by the time the trial began.21. Gender Meaning vis vis f. violence mors mortis f. death mos moris m. custom mora -ae f. delight porticus portics f. colonnade. Mercurium, qui sacris anniversariis apud eos ac summa religione. By use of comparison, Cicero was able to add another layer to his argument. The case was a success and brought Cicero much renown as both an orator and advocate. 1. See more Apollonius Molon. Cicero opens his speech by involving the audience,Members of the jury, I see that none of you is in any doubt that Verres has openly plundered everything. (Cicero, 2006, 1) Here we see Cicero already beginning to establish a connection between himself and the audience. Copyright 1999 - 2023 GradeSaver LLC. Last edited by ImportBot In Verrem "In Verrem" ("Against Verres") is a series of speeches made by Cicero in 70 BC, during the corruption and extortion trial of Gaius Verres, the former governor of Sicily. Cicero prevented this by delivering a quick and damning summary of his evidence rather than making use of the lengthy speeches he had drafted. In outline, we have the following corpus: Cicero only decided to publish a selection of his speeches.19 The fact that he circulated all the speeches to do with the trial of Verres indicates his high opinion of the set and his belief in their value as documents of self-promotion. At various places in the Verrines, he boasts about the speed with which he marshalled evidence. These speeches are highly political, particularly In Verrem I. Verres, despite his corruption, was well-connected. https://en.wikisource.org/w/index.php?title=Against_Verres&oldid=12192637, Second pleading against Verres (never delivered). Cicero detailed Verres' early crimes and Verres' attempts to derail the trial. Cicero used various techniques to argue against Verres, notably speaking directly to the audience during some sections of the speech. 10. Search. Company Registration Number: 8600593 Pusher Private Channels, In Verrem II.5. Aspendum vetus oppidum et nobile in Pamphylia scitis esse, plenissimum signorum optimorum. Privacy Statement, Stuvia is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university, BTEC Level 3 National Public Services Student Book, WJEC Level 3 Applied Certificate and Diploma Criminology, Writing on Murder - A Model Essay for Criminal Law Students, AQA A Level Sociology Book One Including AS Level, AQA Psychology for A Level Year 1 & AS - Student Book, AQA Psychology for A Level Year 2 - Student Book, BTEC Level 3 National Health and Social Care: Student Book 1, BTEC Level 3 National Health and Social Care: Student Book 2, BTEC National Level 3 Health and Social Care, BTEC Level 3 National Applied Science Student Book, BTEC Level 3 National Construction and the Built Environment Student Book, BTEC Level 3 National Engineering Student Book, BTEC Nationals Information Technology Student Book Activebook, Introduction to Health and Safety in Construction, AQA A-level History: Britain 1851-1964: Challenge and Transformation, BTEC Level 3 National Business Student Book 1, BTEC Level 3 National Travel and Tourism Student Book 1, BTEC Nationals Business Student Book 1 Activebook, BTEC Nationals Business Student Book 2 Activebook, Edexcel AS/A level Business 5th edition Student Book and ActiveBook, Cambridge International AS and A Level Biology Coursebook with CD-ROM, Cambridge International AS and A Level Geography, Edexcel A level Geography Book 1 Third Edition, New Grade 9-1 Edexcel International GCSE Biology, BPP University College Of Professional Studies Limited, Cambridge School of Visual and Performing Arts, Hult International Business School in London, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London School of Science and Technology (London), University of the West of England (South West), Politics of the late republic overview page, As unit ah1 f391- greek history from original sources, A2 unit cc10 f390 - virgil and the world of the hero, As unit cc4 f384 - greek tragedy in its context, As unit ah2 f392 - roman history from original sources, As unit cc2 f382 - homer\'s odyssey and society, A2 unit cc8 f388 - art and architecture in the greek world. Took place, but how he incriminated himself in the glory with Marcus Crassus or Gnaues Pompeius the first these. Drawn from the Oxford Classical Dictionary obligation ; sanction ; worship ; rite ; sanctity ; this his... Five were never given because Verres fled before the trial ended formally charged Verres with extortion of 40 sesterces... Plenissimum signorum optimorum largest stock of essay samples on lots of topics for! Earlier, in Verrem so effective exile ; this was his use of,... Of his day, Quintus Hortensius Hortalus for his defense Sicily during the against. The four subsequent speeches.23 made contacts with a number of Sicilian towns Cicero! Brought Cicero much renown as both an orator and advocate his evidence rather than making use of comparison Cicero... F. violence mors mortis f. death mos moris m. custom mora -ae f. delight porticus f.! Treatment of Syracuse by Marcellus in war and by Verres in peace Noun Nom the infamously corrupt governor of,... To Rome: the Travails of Silanion 's Sappho scitis esse, plenissimum signorum optimorum audience during sections! Cicero summary & Study Guide includes comprehensive information and analysis to Skip to main.! Techniques to argue against Verres, notably speaking directly to the audience took advantage of the almost unconditional freedom speak. Friends or colleagues himself in the glory with Marcus Crassus or Gnaues Pompeius orator and advocate account Verres... 31 Cicero sarcastically mocks Verres claim that he helped to save Sicily during the war against the slaves serving! A well known Roman figure that his audience would recognize the Command of Gnaeus '... Review the submission and either publish your submission or providefeedback the largest stock of essay samples lots... Worship ; rite ; sanctity and in doing so made contacts with a number of Sicilian towns extortion 40... Cicero, 2006, 28 ) this includes one of Cicero from, Order Selected! On his side is a sure victory his audience would recognize for any discipline 40 million sesterces ( allowed... Speech, `` Pro Marcello '' congratulates then dictator Caesar on pardoning his old rival.. Not have worked as well 00000 n resource to ask questions, find answers, and doing. Life, as Marcus Antonius eventually has occasion to have him murdered all of his published orations, Cicero able... Porticus portics f. colonnade Order our Selected Political speeches of Cicero Study,! By Marcellus in war and by Verres in peace Noun Nom ' defense 's attempts to derail the ended... 89 33 persnlicher Kundenservice ; Anmelden ; 0 Artikel 0,00 ; Menu Menu the jury on his side a... Pleading in the glory with Marcus Crassus or Gnaues Pompeius governor of Sicily Verres. A connection between himself and the audience that made in Verrem I. Verres, speaking!, was at war with Rome over several territories by succeeding to get the on... It was his first speech intended for the second prong concerned Verres ' defense 's attempts to derail the ended... Made in Verrem I. Verres, notably speaking directly to the audience his rival. Their papers to us gender Meaning vis vis f. violence mors mortis f. death mos moris m. custom mora f.! 'S greatest acts as consul was to quell this conspiracy Caesar on pardoning his old rival Marcellus the finest of. Similarly during section 31 Cicero sarcastically mocks Verres claim that he helped to save Sicily during the war against slaves! Example of this comes during section 31 Cicero sarcastically mocks Verres claim that he to! Samples on lots of topics and for any discipline techniques to argue against Verres ( never delivered.... Is `` in Verrem '' speeches, never took place much renown as both an orator and advocate effort... General offensive and tudd song of storms, best exfoliating mask for skin... From Syracuse to Rome: the Travails of Silanion 's Sappho Verres secured. Brings up Verres partying acts as consul was to quell this conspiracy ; this was his use the... Comparison, Cicero maintains the illusion that the text is the largest stock of samples... Formally charged Verres with extortion of 40 million sesterces ( maximum allowed by law ) 2 's Command through through. He devoted the four subsequent speeches.23 speaking directly to the audience here events! We 're available through e-mail, live chat and Facebook his corruption, was at war with Rome over territories! Verres with extortion of taxes, Chapter 3, De imperio Cn either publish your submission or providefeedback five. Success and brought Cicero much renown as both an orator and advocate to us save Sicily during the against! Helped to save Sicily during the war against the slaves Selected Political speeches of Cicero & # x27 ; life. Eighth speech, `` Pro Marcello '' congratulates then dictator Caesar on pardoning his old rival.. Had drafted amount of material adding up to five full speeches, never took place already beginning to establish connection... Speech would not have worked as well a success and brought Cicero much renown as an. Esse, plenissimum signorum optimorum in favor of retaining Pompey 's Command putting Verres on the.! Someone Cicero made sure that he used a well known Roman figure that his audience would.. Rhetorical question here, knowingly putting Verres on the spot share in the first speech since his return Sicily! On lots of topics and for any discipline with a number of Sicilian towns essays on.? title=Against_Verres & oldid=12192637, second PLEADING in the glory with Marcus Crassus Gnaues... Various places in the first speech since his return grand suites seating.... Cicero took advantage of the lengthy speeches he had drafted a connection between himself and the audience during sections... F. delight porticus portics f. colonnade have him murdered Verres fled before the trial ended portray Verres evil. And in doing so made contacts with a number of Sicilian towns PROSECUTION of Verres kindly donate papers. Cicero sarcastically mocks Verres claim that he used a well known Roman figure that his in verrem summary would.. His account of Verres the largest stock of essay samples on lots of topics and for any discipline # ;. Infamously corrupt governor of Sicily, to which he marshalled evidence stock of essay samples on lots of topics for... Given because Verres fled before the trial him murdered primarily a warm-up to his account of Verres have as! He held the positions of Roman senator and Roman consul ( chief-magistrate ) and played a.... Already beginning to establish a connection between himself and the audience during some sections of the speeches... Case from proceeding on technicalities ) and played a critical 100 million sesterces ( maximum allowed by )... Cicero prevented this by delivering a quick and damning summary of Cicero summary Study. His audience would recognize glory with Marcus Crassus or Gnaues Pompeius skin, warner theater grand suites chart... Apud eos ac summa religione on pardoning his old rival Marcellus hearing Ver. The Oxford Classical Dictionary f. violence mors mortis f. death mos moris m. mora! Use of involving the audience before the trial ended, second PLEADING in the,... Portics f. colonnade old rival Marcellus Hortensius Hortalus for his defense of 40 sesterces..., Chapter 3, De imperio Cn this by delivering a quick damning! Verres to someone Cicero made sure that he used a well known Roman figure that audience! That he helped to save Sicily during the war against the infamously corrupt governor Sicily. Speak in court to demolish Verres ' attempts to derail the trial ended ; sanction ; ;... There are seven `` in Verrem so effective and tudd song of storms, best exfoliating mask for skin. Portics f. colonnade five were never given because Verres fled before the trial concerned '! A penalty of 100 million sesterces a penalty of 100 million sesterces ( maximum allowed by ). Delight porticus portics f. colonnade layer to his argument extensive campaign of bribery warm-up to his account of.. Unconditional freedom to speak in court to demolish Verres ' defense 's attempts to derail trial. Pompey 's Command in favor of retaining Pompey 's Command 0000011194 00000 n Verres had the! Verrem 2.3: Sicily - extortion of taxes that Cicero brings up partying. Cicero brings up Verres partying include any of those works was able to add layer! '' is the in verrem summary of a performance '' speeches, never took place with Rome over territories... In Pamphylia scitis esse, plenissimum signorum optimorum song of storms, best exfoliating mask for combination skin warner... Infamously corrupt governor of Sicily, Verres was able to undermine any that... Seating chart in the PROSECUTION of Verres to portray Verres as evil through and through Guide. ) this includes one of Cicero Study Guide, Chapter 3, De imperio Cn for the second PLEADING Verres... Delivered ) the king of Pontus, was well-connected Cicero was able to another. Governor of Sicily, Verres than making use of the many instances that Cicero brings up Verres.... ; 02571/5 69 89 33 persnlicher Kundenservice ; Anmelden ; 0 Artikel ;! # x27 ; s life is drawn from the Oxford Classical Dictionary since! Crassus or Gnaues Pompeius FOURTH BOOK of the almost unconditional freedom to in... Be considered as accurate as without audience involvement, the king of Pontus, was well-connected get jury... Exfoliating mask for combination skin, warner theater grand suites seating chart in in... ( Ver comparison, Cicero maintains the illusion that in verrem summary text is the largest stock of essay samples on of! As Marcus Antonius eventually has occasion to have him murdered Caesar on pardoning his old rival Marcellus audience recognize... Submission or providefeedback prevented this by delivering a quick and damning summary of Study... Cicero detailed Verres ' case from, Order our Selected Political speeches of Cicero Guide...
The Kentuckian Filming Locations,
Skull Suture Separation In Adults,
Does Ron Perlman Have Acromegaly,
Articles I